Self Esteem, Narcissism, and Willful Ignorance

Over the last 75 years or so, the “experts” have been leading us down the garden path of self-esteem.   Well, you might ask, what’s so bad about a lot of self-esteem? After all, in this country we tend to believe in qualities like self-starting, hard work, and individual freedom – and a good part of applying those traits successfully is developing a sufficient amount of self-esteem (aka confidence) to forge ahead.  

The trouble is, self-esteem is no longer treated as a means to a worthwhile end in this life but has become an end in itself.   And make no mistake: the garden at the end of that garden path is not Eden.   In John Milton’s words, it can be a place of “hideous ruin and combustion down to bottomless perdition” – in other words, the devil’s realm.   Indeed, what makes the all-out pursuit of self-esteem so dangerous is that its handmaidens are often willful ignorance and, worse, moral relativism.  And at the extreme, it becomes narcissism.

The fact is, if “your truth” is whatever feels right or good to you “in the moment,” the chances are you won’t bother to validate or even question much of what you think, say, or do based on your truth.   That’s the willful part of willful ignorance.   Also, your ego would typically balk at any criticism or correction offered by others.   Of course, negative social pressure might later force you to pull in your horns and adopt different truths – possibly even God’s truths – but more likely some other influencer’s truths or those of a charismatic political leader.  

However, there’s often another ingredient in the self-esteem mix besides willful ignorance and moral relativism – namely, the enabler (or cheerleader, if you will).   Typically, self-esteem based on one’s own truths is apt to move toward the extreme in people who have, or are consciously seeking, a sizable “fan base” of enablers (as on X, the former Twitter, or Instagram, etc.), while, at the same time, avoiding responsible critics.   Indeed, with a sizable fan base, such excess self-esteem can lead to clinical narcissism, a personality disorder at the extreme.  

Politics seems to attract people who exhibit these excesses.   For example, back when Barack Obama was a senator, he was interviewed by a Chicago Sun-Times reporter, who asked him: “Do you believe in sin?”   When Obama said “yes,” the reporter asked, “What is sin?”   Obama’s answer was “Being out of alignment with my values.”   In other words, misalignment with his truths, not God’s.

The fact is, the upbringing and education of Barak Obama was abounding with protective (leftist) family and friends, mentors, professors, and fellow students who unfailingly stroked and nurtured his alleged genius until he fervently believed in his own near-infallibility.   He was even awarded a Nobel Peace Prize before he made peace with anyone.   He didn’t make much peace afterwards either.  

Another example of these excesses is former presidential candidate Bernie Sanders.   (Disclosure: I lived 30 years in Vermont while he was mayor of Burlington and a US Congressman and have met him briefly at a couple of meetings.  Now I’m back in Vermont at a time when he is a U.S. Senator and DSA leader.)   You may recall reading that he honeymooned in the former Soviet Union and was “greatly impressed by what he saw.”   Of course, it would be more accurate to say, “by what he was shown.”   The fact is, he willfully ignores past and current history – like the evils and/or failures of the Soviet Union itself, Cuba, Venezuela, China, and North Korea – and stands by the not-so-subtle claim that he’s the one who can do socialism correctly.  Now, after long being viewed as a harmless political eccentric. he has a big fan base – largely because our entire culture is moving leftward.

There is also little doubt that our current president, Donald Trump, is a victim of extreme self-esteem – i.e., narcissism.  He needs (and has) a big and loyal fan base; he does not take sincere criticism well; he has fired people who disagree with him; he seems to operate primarily (and impulsively) on his own truths and notions (one political writer referred to him as capricious); and he seems unable to back down from any action of his that’s clearly failing.  (He has also done many good things – I don’t know how much he loves God, but he does love the country, which is more than can be said for his two predecessors.)

On the other hand, those who adhere to an assemblage of absolute truths – primarily God’s laws (like Speaker Mike Johnson) – are far less apt to overdo the cultivation of self-esteem and drift into narcissism.   More specifically, one who accepts and follows even basic Biblical truths – such as loving God and neighbor, staying faithful in marriage, dealing honestly, not coveting, helping others, and so on – is more apt to keep self-esteem in proper restraint and avoid narcissistic excesses in thoughts and behavior.   This is especially important for leaders in an individualistic society such as ours.  

Awhile back in an October 2019 issue of Chronicles magazine, Dr. Boris Vatel, a long-time practicing psychiatrist, was quoted as follows:

“Culturally individualistic societies are more prone to give rise to individual and collective narcissism than collectivist societies, in which, by definition, the collective good is viewed as superior to the individual good.   I would also submit that, to the extent that cultures preferring individual achievement over group achievement lose their internally shared notions of normality (morality, behavior, dress, culture, etc.), their members become atomized, autistic, and [their] narcissistic tendencies will become more and more prominent.”

In other words, while we value individualism and a healthy amount of self-esteem, we need to keep it in check – e.g., with traditional sources of morality and authority.  For most of that, we need to look to the Bible – especially Jesus’s commandments to love God and love our neighbors as ourselves.   A healthy fear of eternal perdition is another restraining factor.   In short, the more time we spend focusing on Godly matters outside ourselves, the less time we spend on self-centered thoughts and behaviors.   And that’s really the essence of the humility that we are commanded to live by – not thinking less of ourselves but thinking of ourselves less.  

The quote by Dr. Vatel noted that narcissism is much less prevalent in collectivist societies.   Was he implying that socialism is the best means to keep individual and collective narcissism in check?   That’s doubtful.  There are certainly better ways to deal with narcissists than converting an entire society to a failed system.

                                           Norbert J. Kuk